by jimwalton » Tue Feb 12, 2019 2:57 am
Well, I would certainly disagree that the whole story is a metaphor for our journey through life. Instead, I take it as historical narrative.
In Deuteronomy 32.51, Moses is told by God why he's not allowed to enter the Promised Land, despite his long walk, and is to die on the doorstep. "This is because both of you broke faith with me in the presence of the Israelites...and because you did not uphold my holiness..." It's a specific reference to Numbers 20.10-11, where Moses disobeyed God. But there's more to it.
The comments in Numbers 20 indicate that, in general, Moses was guilty (at least to some extent) of the same rebellious attitude against God that characterized all the people who were not permitted to enter the Promised Land. In Numbers 20.10, he accuses the people of being rebellious, but then hypocritically, he acts as a rebel himself by striking the rock. He is motivated by anger and frustration (the complaint motif) just like the people are. He fails to bring glory to God, just like the people. He doesn't show full trust in God, just like the people. He fails to display humility, just like the people. Etc. Etc.
In essence, sadly, Moses becomes somewhat the archetype of the rebellious generation, and his act of striking the rock is the straw that defined it (just as Adam and Eve eating the fruit was theirs). His sin by striking the rock was a glaring example of all that was wrong with the "sinful generation" that was not allowed to enter the Promised Land, and therefore Moses was not allowed to enter either.
Well, I would certainly disagree that the whole story is a metaphor for our journey through life. Instead, I take it as historical narrative.
In Deuteronomy 32.51, Moses is told by God why he's not allowed to enter the Promised Land, despite his long walk, and is to die on the doorstep. "This is because both of you broke faith with me in the presence of the Israelites...and because you did not uphold my holiness..." It's a specific reference to Numbers 20.10-11, where Moses disobeyed God. But there's more to it.
The comments in Numbers 20 indicate that, in general, Moses was guilty (at least to some extent) of the same rebellious attitude against God that characterized all the people who were not permitted to enter the Promised Land. In Numbers 20.10, he accuses the people of being rebellious, but then hypocritically, he acts as a rebel himself by striking the rock. He is motivated by anger and frustration (the complaint motif) just like the people are. He fails to bring glory to God, just like the people. He doesn't show full trust in God, just like the people. He fails to display humility, just like the people. Etc. Etc.
In essence, sadly, Moses becomes somewhat the archetype of the rebellious generation, and his act of striking the rock is the straw that defined it (just as Adam and Eve eating the fruit was theirs). His sin by striking the rock was a glaring example of all that was wrong with the "sinful generation" that was not allowed to enter the Promised Land, and therefore Moses was not allowed to enter either.