I'd most likely identify myself as a liberal Christian, but I am really questioning the existence of hell. The possible scenarios are:
1. Hell is exactly as evangelical's describe it (non-Christians go there , no second chance). In this scenario, God would be evil, unfair, and unjust (I can elaborate on this if you ask). Free-will would not exist (well, it would be pseudo free-will). It'd be just like saying "Here, pick either of these! Oh but if you're unfortunate enough to pick the wrong thing then you'll be eternally condemned to torture." Also, God would not "win" if this idea of hell was reality.
2. Hell does exist, but non-believers have a second chance (after they die). This is more reasonable, but would anyone really go against God once they recognized His existence? Hell would be pretty much empty.
3. Hell doesn't exist. For those who still went against God after their death, they would not enter heaven, but instead be "outside" of it. Not in hell, not in heaven.
These are pretty much my three different ways of thinking of this (besides neither exist/ God doesn't exist, but that's a different argument). What are your thoughts? Every way seems full of problems.